Jimmy Carter vs. Blessed Virgin Mary Regarding the Male Priest

President Carter seems very concerned about the Catholic doctrine of the male priesthood. Speaking at the Carter Center’s “Mobilizing Faith for Women” the former President answered some questions about women and religion. Let’s look at his words against the Catholic Church and then I’ll provide three systematic responses:

“And I think the great religions have set the example for that, by ordaining, in effect, that women are not equal to men in the eyes of God. This has been done and still is done by the Catholic Church ever since the third century, when the Catholic Church ordained that a woman cannot be a priest for instance but a man can. A woman can be a nurse or a teacher but she can’t be a priest. This is wrong, I think. 

And again, President Carter says: “And then after about the third century when men took over control of the Catholic Church, then they began to ordain that women had to play an inferior position, not be a priest.”

Now I can understand where President Carter is coming from. First, he and his wife are Baptists. As Baptists they do not believe in a sacerdotal doctrine of the priesthood. 
Unlike the Baptists, the Catholic Church believes that the priesthood is not merely a ministerial function or office. Rather, when a man is ordained a priest, he is configured to Christ in a special way. His soul changes. We call this the indelible seal or character of Holy Orders. This is why there have never been women priests in the Catholic Church – not in the third, second, or first century. Never.
1. Jimmy Carter, Let’s Take a Look at the Mystery of the Transubstantiation
Not only does the priest’s soul undergo a metaphysical change, but the priest loans his own body and voice to Christ when he recites in the Holy Mass “This is my body.” This act transubstantiates bread into the true Body of Christ.
Let’s pause here. This is my body. Human bodies come in two versions: male and female. God designed it this way. Both sexes image God because, as the Church teaches, both sexes are ensouled and rational. See Genesis for details.
However, when the priest says, “This is my body,” he is acting in persona Christi (in the person of Christ). Now then Christ is male. He was circumcised. The body that He offered on the cross was male. For this reason, only men can be priests because the Catholic Church mystically identifies the male Body of Christ with each and every male priest. The sacramental signification requires a man to stand in for the God-Man Jesus Christ at the altar.
2. Jimmy Carter and Clericalism
Secondly, President Carter unknowingly slips into clericalism. Clericalism is the insidious belief that clergy are de facto holier and more important than everyone else. As a Baptist, he likely sees his pastor as a CEO and/or a gifted public speaker. These functions parallel those of secular companies. Hence, to exclude women is, in his mind, sexist.
But the Catholic Church does not see priests as CEOs or primarily as preachers/teachers. Rather, priests are chiefly “fathers.” Their relationship to other people is not transactional, it’s paternal. Only a dad can be a dad. Again, it’s a male thing. The Aramaic word for “father” is Abba meaning “giver of love.”
3. Jimmy Carter, please meet the Blessed Virgin Mary

Here’s the third and final thought:
I’d like to point out that the Catholic Church explicitly teaches that the greatest human person ever created is the Blessed Virgin Mary.

Mary is not only a woman, she is the Woman. The Catholic Church also teaches that she is higher than all Catholic priests, even higher than the twelve apostles. In fact, she is higher than every single angel. 

The priesthood, even the papacy, is not the highest “job” in the Catholic Church. In fact, the Catholic Church features many beautiful female saints in the canon of the Mass. I would even argue that the Catholic Church celebrates femininity more than any other religion and certainly more than any other Christian denomination. 
At the end of the day, the Catholic Church teaches that it is holiness and intimacy with Christ that is most important, not being a priest. As a former Episcopal priest, I could go on to be a married Catholic priest. But I chose not to do so. Why? Because I realized that my personal “yes” to God is enough. Nothing more is needed of me. 
I love priests. I kiss the hand of every priest I meet. I truly love priests because without them there is no Holy Eucharist and no supernatural life in the world. However, as my former spiritual director Father Ron Gillis (who died just last week) taught me, “At the front of most Catholic churches are not side altars dedicated to Peter and Paul, but to Joseph and Mary – a reminder that the priesthood supports the Church and not the other way around.” 
That’s a beautiful and simple lesson for all of us.
May Father Ron Gillis rest in peace. It’s too bad that he could not have shared that insight with President Jimmy Carter.
Fr Ron Gillis, rest in peace. Please say a Hail Mary for the repose of his soul.
Do you enjoy reading these posts by Dr. Taylor Marshall? Make it easier to receive  new daily posts. Receive these blog posts through email free by clicking here.
Privacy Guarantee: Your e-mail will never be shared with anyone. 
Also, please check out my brand new book The Eternal City: Rome & the Origins of Catholicism at amazon.com by clicking here.
Download My Book for Free
Thomas Aquinas in 50 Pages
Over 15,000 copies downloaded! This is a quick and easy way to learn the basic philosophy and theology of Saint Thomas Aquinas. The Popes of the last 300 years have endorsed St Thomas Aquinas. Learn more through this accessible resources. Download it for free.

Comments Policy: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic. If your comment contains a hyperlink to another site, your comment automatically goes into "Comments Purgatory" where it waits for release by way of moderation.

  • Deborist Benjamin

    Sacerdotal, I just like saying it! Great article, now I am off to 5:15 mass at St. Mary Magdalene in Camarillo Ca. I will say a prayer for Fr. Gillis.

  • givelifeachance2

    This is very useful. I wonder if you could elaborate on the necessity of a male-identifying (ie, heterosexual) person in persona Christi. In other words is a homosexual priest an oxymoron for the same or similar reason a woman priest is?

  • UAWildcatx2

    Any time Carter talks about religion, and ESPECIALLY the Catholic Church I just hear white noise. It is unbelievably clear that he has no idea what he’s talking about, and views everything through his own “progressive” lenses. Add to that the fact the he was once talking about his writing his own interpretation of scripture…

  • lizzysimplymagic

    Who could say, “this is my Body, this is my Blood”, with more authenticity than the Virgin Mary herself? To say there has never been a female priest is to ignore the Christian story. The first priest was Mary herself. She is the only one who was there from Christ’s conception to his sacrifice on Calvary.

    “Mary is no stranger in anything that belongs to the Eucharist. She was the first priest to call down the Word from heaven to earth and to bring forth Jesus Christ in this world through an act of her will. Therefore she has been called Virgin Priest, Virgo Sacerdos . . . .” – Bishop Morelle, Troisième congrès marial breton, Saint-Brieuc 1911.